Visit the full NBR website
HomeOpinion  

Auckland man buys Game of Thrones, Season 3, on iTunes Australia

UPDATE / June 12, 2013:  The Game of Thrones Season 3 final set ratings and piracy records

HBO says 6.3 million watched the show on Sunday night US time - a 28% increase on the season two finale, despite it going head-to-head with the NBA finals. Counting HBO's various digital delivery services, the total audience was 13.6 million. 

And according to TorrentFreak, one million people illegally downloaded a file of the show during the day after it screened.

Many probably Torrented the show here, too (not that there's any chance of them being caught).

Numbers were possibly dampened by the fact Sky TV screened the finale here within hours the US - a shift from season two, when a two-week delay helped send NZ internet traffic through the roof as the impatient hit the Torrents (there have been local grumblings about delays with season 5 of Breaking Bad, however).

But ... I'm not a Sky TV subscriber. In this age of content everywhere, I don't see any reason to be, unless you're a committed fan of live rugby (happily for Sky TV, many New Zealanders are. Sky TV's worst nightmare has to be an Australian-style anti-siphoning law. It can sleep easy; our law makers show no interest.

Intriguingly, Sky TV co-founder Craig Heatley - who sold his stake years ago - is shaping to launch a service to bring big sports event to mobile. But at this stage it's unclear if he will agitate for real change, or simply become another delivery platform for Sky).

I'm happy with my Freeview PVR for recording local free-to-air channels, and the internet for sourcing other series, and movies. 

On this point, a reader emailed asking if I had bought Game of Thrones season three on iTunes US (a better option than waiting aeons for it to eventually appear on Sky TV's free-to-air Prime).

I hadn't; it's not available through iTunes US yet. Happily, iTunes Australia has been offering season three GoT episodes within hours of the US screening ($A2.99 in standard definition, $A3.49 high definition; $A33.99 for a season pass; the biggest toll can be on your data cap with each episode running to 2GB. The Aussie version of QuickFlix also offers Throne.).

Sadly, it seems like it's end of the golden weather on that front, with Foxtel moving to block iTunes Australia from speedily offering future seasons.

A new wrinkle
As ever, iTunes US and iTunes Australia ask for a local credit card, but will also accept US or Australian iTunes gift card vouchers, which are freely available over the internet (the US also sees an Air NZ air points credit card as a US card; the latter option also gives you access to live-streaming services Netflix and Hulu, which partner with Apple TV). 

There is a wrinkle since we last checked in: Apple won't let me toggle between multiple country accounts on my Apple TV anymore (an Apple TV being the $149, paperback-sized gadget that connects your regular television to your broadband connection, by wi-fi or cable).

But recently, an Apple pop up message told me I could only use one account per device, and would have to wait 90 days before logging on to another. With my Apple TV currently logged in to my iTunes US account, that meant waiting three months until I would log-on to my iTunes Australia account.

Happily, as ever, there was a loophole. I could still log in to iTunes Australia from another device. I duly logged in via my iPad, whose AirPlay feature lets you simply click an icon as a video is playing for it to stream it to your television. It's a very user-friendly set up.

Of course, it's quite possible Apple will change the rules on me again without notice. It's quite entitled to do so given accessing other countries' iTunes stores breaches its terms and conditions (if not any NZ law; see Chapman Tripp opinion end of article). I hope not. I respect copyright, but not tired regional distribution monopolies. I'm willing to pay Apple (or Hulu or Netflix) for on-demand content.I hope they keep taking my money.

iTunes NZ offers a so-so collection of movies, and no TV series. The Commerce Commission's mulling over whether an investigation is warranted into Sky TV's content partnerships, and whether they stop new market entrants from gaining a critical mass of content, grinds on (it began May 16, 2012, with no deadline).

Sky TV CEO John Fellet says the company's MySky decoder will be upgraded to directly support iSky - meaning you'll be able to easily watch iSky content on a TV rather than a PC. That's a good thing, but it's only playing catch-up with other countries. We need competition to spur technology innovation. 

On a related note, check out this article on US pay TV broadcaster Comcast, whose latest settop box has no hard drive - all of your recordings are stored in the cloud. Nice. It's good to see providers competing on price, and who's got the most useful, user-friendly service rather than who's got content rights stitched up.

Change will come. Our politicians may never give Sky TV a nudge. But as Google (via YouTube), Apple and others expand their ability to deliver high definition content to any TV, planet-wide, technology is going to overtake politics. And while Telecom and TVNZ don't have the money or stomach to wrestle content rights for major sports events or series off Sky TV, just imagine if, say, Google opened its wallet.

ckeall@nbr.co.nz


Auckland man buys Game of Thrones, Season 2 on iTunes Australia

UPDATE / Dec 13, 2012: I joined iTunes Australia over the weekend. 

Like iTunes US (of which I'm also a member), it sportingly lets you pay for content using iTunes vouchers rather than giving details for a local credit card. And no, I'm not breaking the law (see the Chapman Tripp comments below). Vouchers can be bought on eBay Australia or sometimes Trade Me.

My purpose in joining iTunes Australia: to buy Season 2 of Homeland (having missed the first few episodes, and not wanting to watch them on a laptop). Apple and HBO took my money. I downloaded the shows to my Apple TV box in NZ to watch on my television. 

As a bonus, I discovered iTunes Australia also had Game of Thrones Season 2 for sale (it's not on iTunes US until next April; iTunes NZ offers no TV shows).

I bought that too.

Each series was about 16GB in HD, and is now stashed on my generation 1 Apple TV (Apple's $159 wi-fi widget for watching content downloaded from iTunes on a regular television. As I've written before, I cling to my gen 1 Apple TV because it has a hard dive, unlike later models that stream content or pull it off a laptop or other device with a hard drive).

Everybody's happy. 

Except maybe Sky TV.

The Wall Street Journal reports today that Apple TV sales have been modest (around 1 millon in the past quarter). The company is said to now be looking at making its own television set, and is in trials with Foxcon (which recentlly began making big screen LCDs TVs) and others.

It'll be interesting to watch this space, but as the Journal notes Apple has been circling this space for years (even if Tim Cook now seems to have greater urgency). And, as with so many things content-related, it hinges on what deals can be stuck with rights holders and/or regional TV providers - most of whom trying to hold back the new technology tide that will someday overwhelm their cosy regional content distribution monopolies.

New Telecom boss Simon Moutter thinks a day will come when technology change means the likes of HBO renegotiate their regional distribution deals on different terms.

What a happy day that will be.

As Netflix has shown by eclipsing BitTorrent in US data traffic, when people are given the chance to do the right thing, most do.

Sky TV boss John Fellet says his company has no monopoly, because so-called over-the-top services like iTunes represent a clear competitive threat over the next few years.

To a degree, he might just be trying to get the Commerce Commisson off his back as it continues its endless investigation into whether the nature of Sky TV content deals prevent rivals (which would include the ill-fated Quickflix) from gaining a critical mass of content.

But the irony is, he's right.

(Don't panic Sky TV investors, as long as the company keeps its exclusive rights to live All Blacks rugby - don't look too hard at Australia with its anti-siphoning law - and offers the most user-friendly way to watch and record other content, it will continue to prosper.)

ckeall@nbr.co.nz


The Game of Thrones effect: Season 2 debut sends NZ-US internet traffic through the roof

UPDATE April 5, 2011: I was just talking to the boss of one of our largest ISPs.

He said international data traffic went through the roof last Tuesday. As in completely blew the lid off. 

There a huge spike in data being sucked down from the US.

That was the day when the first episode of Game of Thrones, season two, debuted on HBO in the US (Monday US time).

Season two doesn't start on Sky TV until April 16 (although there was an iSky preview on April 4).

So it seems a huge number of Kiwis could not wait for April 16.

Or, if they're not Sky TV subscribers, were not willing to wait a half-year or longer to appear on disc (and, alas, in terms of standalone download services it will never appear on NZ newcomer QuickFlix, despite HBO's $A10 million investment, due to Sky TV having rights locked up. Same goes for the hapless iTunes NZ).

I'm not willing to break the law, but I am willing to break Apple's terms and conditions to commercially access the US version of iTunes (see details below), whose movie and TV section boasts everything iTunes NZ lacks, including a good section of movies, and new-release HBO shows.  And it can all be streamed from your broadband internet connection to your regular television, in high def, via a $159 Apple TV gadget.

iTunes US is not offering Game of Thrones season two yet (or it seems rivals like Hulu) - so I'm guessing a bunch of that New Zealanders downloaded it illegally.

You could see on social media that many were torn (including one member of John Key's staff). They didn't want to break the law. But, boy, they loved their Game of Thrones, and it was just so tempting to download a dose.

Most would pay if given the chance, as the commercial NetFlix has proved in the US by moving ahead of BitTorrent in traffic terms.

But if they're not given a commercial download option, and they need it now, well .... look at what happened.

How long can the entertainment industry stay at war with its own customers?

A lot of people have asked me how iTunes US is going.

It rocks. It's changed my life, or at least the TV and movie and part of it.

It's a wonderland of great, up-to-date content (ironically, a Games of Thrones seasons one delay was one of my few disappointments; it only recently came available).

And my ISP and Apple are doing very nicely from me, thank you very much, as I repeatedly stock up on iTunes credit, and top up my data cap.


Is it legal to buy from iTunes US? Probably.

Dec 16, 2011: I’m trying to be a good digital citizen.

But it’s hard.

Take Game of Thrones, Season 1.

While others downloaded it from illegal sources, I ordered the series from Amazon ($63.99 after shipping, thank you very much). 

That was on September 1.

Amazon recently emailed to say it would arrive in March or April.

I’m happy to give Game of Thrones’ producers (HBO) my money.

But they won’t take it.

It’s not copyright that’s being protected here, by Sky TV’s programming monopoly.

I mentioned my dilemma on Twitter.

A prominent blogger, and an IT industry exec both emailed me about an interesting alternative for commercial downloads: buying from iTunes US – which offers a far larger collection of movies and TV series than iTunes NZ (in the latter category that’s not hard; iTunes NZ offers none).

I had assumed you needed a US credit card.

But, in fact, iTunes US lets you purchase content without ever supplying credit card details if you have iTunes US gift vouchers – and a number of sites have sprung up that will buy iTunes US vouchers on your behalf that you can then redeem from NZ (you pay the middle men using Pay Pal). You can also simply buy iTunes gift cards through any mainstream US e-tailer like Amazon - although you may find a bar on shipping to NZ - or via eBay.

I was dubious. Who the heck was behind these sites?

But the people who recommended them had both been using them long term.

“It’ll change your life,” said one.

It would. Imagine being able to buy a movie, or TV episode, whenever you wanted, rather than wait months for it to (maybe) appear on iTunes NZ, iSky (which holds local on-demand rights – or at least first-refusal rights on most content) or another local source.

It would make sense for me, and the US artists I’m paying.

But would it be in keeping with New Zealand’s copyright law?

In short: probably.

(See my correspondence with Chapman Tripp’s Justin Graham below (I also consulted a second lawyer, who did not want to go on the record but agreed with Mr Graham. A similar legal situation applies to another jape: signing up to a US commercial streaming service like Netflix from NZ using  technology that masks your true internet address and location.)

But it would break Apple’s terms and conditions. A spokeswoman for Apple confirmed to NBR yesterday that you have to be a US resident to buy from iTunes US (and an NZ resident to buy from iTunes NZ).

Whether Apple would want to go to war with its own customers, who are willing to pay for content, is another matter.

The company says it uses compliance technology, but the spokeswoman wouldn’t comment on what it entailed, or whether it was actively used. The experience of the two people who messaged me suggests it’s not.

You’ve also got to wonder why iTunes US lets people buy content without validating their identity with credit card details (Apple's support forum even helpfully guides you through the process. I put the NZ consulate in New York as my address because, heck, it represents all New Zealanders, and I'm a taxpayer). Or at least, NZ content rights holders would have to wonder. I guess the answer is, simply, that to Apple, a New Zealander’s money is just as good as an American’s.



RAW DATA

Hi Justin,

I was musing on Twitter last night about the lack of commercial download options in NZ.

A number of people suggest I try a site that lets you buy Apple iTunes vouchers for iTunes US - which apparently lets you sign up to the US version of the service (which has many more movies and TV series for sale than iTunes NZ) without the need for a US credit card.

http://www.mediawob.com/
http://itunes-express.web.officelive.com/default.aspx

[UPDATE: One NZ-based iTunes US customer told me he simply uses any mainstream US e-tailer to buy iTunes US vouchers. You can also get them through eBay.]

An NZ based IT exec told me he's been using one of these sites long term, and it works well. So did others.

Apparently the practice - which I'm probably going to write about for NBR - breaks iTunes terms and conditions (Alex is checking). And I guess a local broadcast/download rights holder like Sky TV would not be thrilled.

But would it be illegal?

May also cover the parallel debate about using a VPN to access services like Netflix (there's already been some legal commentary on that question on PC World - here).

Any comments will be on the record unless you indicate otherwise.

Thanks,
CK


Hi Chris


A really interesting question!

As a matter of copyright law, I’m inclined to think it is a similar situation to parallel importing (in the sense that the material has been put on the market with the consent of the copyright holder in another jurisdiction and the downloader is effectively the “importer”, taking advantage in this instance not so much of price, but of availability).

It could be argued that commercially downloading in this way amounts to circumvention of a technological protection measure (which is unlawful under the Copyright Act) but I don’t think bypassing a local content provider meets the required definition. What the downloader is doing is circumventing a service, not a particular protection measure (such as a password), although particular circumstances may differ.

Equally, the definition of a technological protection measure expressly excludes a system to the extent that it controls geographic market segmentation by preventing the playback in New Zealand of a non-infringing copy of the work (which is arguably the position a downloader here faces).

As a result, as a matter of copyright, there might not be infringement because of New Zealand’s position on parallel importing and overall political position we tend to adopt here that we want more content available more cheaply. And since the copies being downloaded are genuine copies, there shouldn’t be any issue with the “3 strikes” law either.

However, if the downloader is breaking the terms and conditions of trade of a local content provider, than that would be a breach of contract and actionable by the local service (and so unlawful). Whether the local service would consider it commercially prudent to take action is another matter – it’s an unattractive position to sue people to keep them bound to a less useful service.

What we may end up seeing ultimately is a situation similar to the format-shifting problem, where everyone was doing it, but it was technically a breach (although in that case of copyright) until the law caught up.

Kind regards
Justin

JUSTIN GRAHAM
PRINCIPAL
CHAPMAN TRIPP 


Another lawyer, who did not want to go the record, offered:

Geez how many times must I correct people who think that circumvention of a TPM [technological prevention measure] is a breach of copyright in itself. ITS NOT!!

The TPM provisions “outlaw” trafficking in TPM circumvention devices but say nothing about using them.

So, combine that with the fact, correctly pointed out [by Chapman Tripp's Justin Graham, above], that zone controls are explicitly excluded from the TPM regime and I think the answer is pretty clear.

The only recourse would be via the terms of use. Not sure what is meant by “local” terms of use. There are no NZ terms of use that are involved here – the only terms of use that could apply would be the US provider’s ones. They may say something about zone controls but often will not. Even if they did say that buying outside the US was a breach, having paid the legitimate price for a legitimate copy,

It’s hard to see where the damage is. Yes, in theory, the local exclusive distributor might be able to take action I guess, like the old days when perfume importers used to take action in respect of grey market imports of perfume sourced legitimately overseas but, unlike those actions, there is no central importer to target so action against each individual who might does this would be uneconomic.

Also, the explicit exclusion of zone controls might make a court decide that, in fact, the intention was to allow this sort of activity so by no means open and shut even if exclusive NZ distributor did take action.

More by this author

Comments and questions

Chris - You don't have to watch episodes of Homeland "on a Laptop".

You simply connect your Laptop to your HD TV via HDMI & you can then stream it from TV3 On Demand - if that is what you are referring to.

I want high definition. TVNZ and TV3 on-demand content is standard definition, at best.

And I just want to touch a button on my remote to watch it, not hook up my laptop (or stream it from a PC).

HD is indeed essential to truly appreciate this new breed of film quality shows: Thrones, Walking Dead, Homeland, Pillars of the Earth etc not to mention the beauty of BBC docos (esp. Attenborough)

Similarly the perennially unrecognised epicness of decent surround sound (none of this cheap *****; one can easily put together a quality Polk/Denon system for under $1K off Trademe). Attenborough Spy on the Wildebeest in 1080p + DTS 5.1 is something else.

Chris where's your HTPC; still kicking off the shackles of misplaced Apple fanboydom perhaps?

I've got a Windows PC and an Apple iPad and a Google Android-based Galaxy Tab 10 tablet at home. I don't want to have to make sure one of them is on or charged before I perform the simple task of watching a movie.

At AUD35.00 for Season 2 I can buy 4 months of Soho (thats longer than the GOT season) and get plenty of other quality Soho content essentially for free.

Yep. everybody's happy that you bought from iTunes. Makes me feel like I get a bargain for timely drama in NZ.

Yes that would buy four months of the cost of the Soho premium channel ... or a couple of weeks of a monthly Sky TV subscription.

Glad that works for you.

But I've chosen to put my money behind Apple TV + Freeview.

And btw while it happens that I don't subscribe to Sky TV, lots of people who download movies etc do subscribe; in my experience they often do.

But you can only buy that Soho access if you already paying for a ~$50 per month Sky subscription, and if you want it in HD you need to get the MySky Box AND HD ticket, another $25 per month. So the minimum price to access the entire GOT series on Soho, which runs for 3 months, is 3 months at $85 = a lot more than $35.

PLUS with Soho you have to wait for each episode to be broadcaset - a pain in the butt when buying/pirating the content allows you to watch what you want when you want.
Not to mention that with Soho you are restricted to watching via the Sky set top box, or, at lower quality, via iSky, which can only be done via a wbe browser. Downloading from iTunes lets you watch on iPad, iPhone, Mac, Apple TV.

Sadly, Fellet and his crew have and will continue to lock down key content such as HBO. Has anyone looked at what content is being downloaded via peer to peer? Understand that and you have the makings of a great service. I hope Netflix makes it to NZ soon as that would break things wide open.

You are living in the future by using a hack to legally buy content. I do the same with Netflix. Hopefully we get some more video content options shortly like we got for music with Rdio, Spotify and Deezer.

Well done in getting GOT season 2. I would love Netflix top come here but the way the content providers jealously guard their content vaults we're unlikely to see it in our lifetime. The latest one I've seen locked out to kiwis because of Sky is NBL.TV. You can't buy a sub from NZ to watch NBL basketball..
If we ever do see TV here via the likes of iTunes it will just be the old crap that the networks have shown here not the nice new stuff.

I would hardly call iTunes NZ content as so-so.

It's downright cr*p. I got an Apple TV. What a waste of money. iTunes NZ simply has bugger all movie content for rent.

While it's not Apple's fault, I can see why so many people download illegal content. Try finding the movie The Usual Suspects from 15 years ago. No video store has it, iTunes doesn't have it, nor does The Warehouse or JB Hifi. I bet torrent has it, though. If someone is willing to confirm?

An America coming from the USA to live here would just die in regards to TV!
You guys got Netflix? No
Hulu? No
Cable? No
NBL? No
Your iTunes Store has nothing on it! Yip
Is this all the channels? Yip
What's a data cap? You don't want to know...

Chris - The Lannisters send their regards.

I have a USA account so I buy the episodes of the shows I want 24 hours after they have aired there.

" (a better option than waiting aeons for it to eventually appear on Sky TV's free-to-air Prime)"
It finished on Sky on June 10 - starts on Prime on June 19?
Aeons.

« Back to home page